Italy’s data protection authority has imposed an €805 million penalty on Meta over a Facebook for Android feature that recommends photos and videos from a user’s phone gallery for sharing on the platform.
The Garante said the feature was activated by default and could access gallery content and associated metadata without obtaining consent that was sufficiently specific and informed. According to the authority, Facebook’s Android permission flow bundled gallery access with other app functions, making it unclear that users were also enabling the gallery-suggestion capability.
The decision concerns roughly 20 million Android users in Italy. The regulator said that broad device permissions can allow continuing access to an entire photo archive, while users and regulators may be unable to determine exactly which items are accessed.
The authority found that Meta violated Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive. Under those rules, access to information stored on a person’s device generally requires freely given and informed consent, regardless of whether the data is transferred elsewhere or causes demonstrable harm.
Required changes
- Within 60 days, Meta must disable the feature by default, including for people who previously gave Facebook gallery permissions.
- The company must present a separate consent request that clearly explains the feature’s purpose, its gallery access, and how users can deactivate it.
- Meta must provide the Garante with an initial progress update within 30 days and a report on completed measures within 90 days.
If Meta does not meet the consent requirements, the feature cannot be enabled for users who have not provided valid approval, the authority said.
Meta said it plans to challenge the decision, describing the fine as disproportionate. The company maintained that the feature operates only after a user grants device-level permission and that those permissions can be changed in phone settings.
The investigation began in July 2025 following a consumer complaint and included technical analysis by the regulator. The Garante said the penalty, equivalent to about 0.47% of Meta’s worldwide revenue, reflected the scale and duration of the alleged breach, as well as factors including a previous 2019 ruling involving the company. The inquiry did not assess whether gallery material was used for AI-model training, which Meta has denied.
