Online safety specialists told a UK parliamentary committee that major technology companies may be meeting the minimum requirements of the Online Safety Act while failing to adequately protect people from harmful material.
During a hearing of Parliament’s Communications and Digital Committee, witnesses raised concerns about the way search engines and social platforms handle content linked to sexual violence, abuse and exploitation. The discussion focused on companies including Google, Microsoft, Meta and ByteDance, as well as the effectiveness of regulatory enforcement.
Search ranking concerns
Clare McGlynn, a Durham University law professor who researches violence against women and girls, said search providers appear to suppress some harmful terms but do not apply those measures consistently. She told lawmakers that terms closely associated with prohibited or extreme sexual content can produce substantially different results depending on small wording changes.
McGlynn argued that search companies could take a more systematic approach by identifying related terms and reducing their visibility. She said similar problems could be observed across more than one search engine, not only Google.
Alexandra Whiston-Dew, a partner at law firm Miscon de Reya, said search engines have an important role in limiting access to sites that openly advertise illegal material. She added that Ofcom, the UK regulator responsible for online safety, faces constraints on its resources and will need cooperation from companies across the publishing and hosting chain.
Declining response rates
Janaya Walker of the End Violence Against Women Coalition cited figures from charity Refuge indicating that the success rate for reports submitted by its Trusted Flagger team had declined. According to the data discussed at the hearing, successful outcomes fell from 53.7% before November 2025 to 18.2% during the following 12 months. Refuge’s figures also indicated that none of its reports to Meta had resulted in successful action in that period.
Meta did not provide an immediate response to the reported figures. Its transparency reporting says it removed millions of posts involving adult nudity and sexual activity during one quarter of 2026, though it does not separately identify reports involving violence against women and girls. Google, Microsoft and TikTok also did not immediately comment.
Witnesses called for stronger accountability, including possible civil redress options that would allow victims to seek rapid removal of harmful images and other material. They pointed to Canadian measures in British Columbia as one model that could inform future UK policy.
